Home
Cafe Menu (in store only)
Signature Cakes
Flavors & How to Order
Cupcakes!
Mother's Day
Sheet Cakes
Cookies and Cheesecakes
Pies
Gluten-Free & Vegan
Rustic Wedding Cakes
Themed Wedding Cakes
Traditional Wedding Cakes
Retro & Vintage Cakes
Custom Design Cakes
Sweet Tables
Wedding Cake Ordering Guide
Our Quality Pledge
Menu
For Cake Lovers
Home
Cafe Menu (in store only)
Signature Cakes
Flavors & How to Order
Cupcakes!
Mother's Day
Sheet Cakes
Cookies and Cheesecakes
Pies
Gluten-Free & Vegan
Rustic Wedding Cakes
Themed Wedding Cakes
Traditional Wedding Cakes
Retro & Vintage Cakes
Custom Design Cakes
Sweet Tables
Wedding Cake Ordering Guide
Our Quality Pledge
Filter
All
Breakfast & Brunch
Cake
Classic Desserts
Cupcake Shakes
cupcakes
Graduation
Signature Cakes
Unicorn Cake
from $55.00
6" Buttercream Cake, 2 Styles Available
from $40.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Cake
from $45.00
Naked Elvis Cake
from $28.00
Traditional Birthday Cake
from $28.00
Brooklyn Blackout Cake
from $49.50
Cookies and Cream Cake
from $45.00
Kolaczki Cake, 8"
$70.00
Carrot Cake
from $28.00
Rainbow Cake
from $50.00
Coconut Raspberry Dream Cake
from $28.75
Salted Caramel Chocolate Crunch Cake
from $45.00
Italian Lover's Cake
from $45.00
Sour Cream Pound Cake, Whole
$22.50
Giant Chocolate Chip Cookie or Brownie "Cake"
$38.00